Pnas Pending Final Recommendation Meaning, The status updates on the PNAS submission website are a little cryptic if you don't understand their process, so I'm going to end by copying and pasting my status updates along with my understanding of what they mean. When reviews are complete it goes to "pending decision" In my experience it was a very quick process (around 10-14 days from submission to under review, then around a month for the reviews). View your paper was a major revision that. Does pending decision mean rejection? the timeline for pending decisions depends on journal and editor. My understanding is that the editor has made the decision based on the reviews, but they have now passed the decision to the editor-in-chief. My manuscript says it’s under “pending recommendation” for few days. My feeling is that this statement is disingenuous. It looks like successful submissions get "under review" -> "under editor review" -> "pending recommendation" but mine got "under review" -> "pending recommendation". will it be desk rejected? Yes this is definitely a desk reject. Thanks for your valuable answers as my own experience, pending decision after with editor, it means rejection/send back to the author. My status at PNAS is Pending Recommendation Under Editorial Board Review Quality Control Review Completed Quality Control Issue Identified Quality Control Review Started Author Approved Submission Is it desk rejected?? in the same situation now. 我经过三个月的补实验和修改论文，年后投回，两天就review结束了现在是Pending Final Recommendation状态已经4天了。 并且PNAS的主编不是我的文章的editor给我发了封信全文如下： Your manusc […] PNAS的投稿状态underreview后20天变成pendingfinalrecommendation，已经7天了，还是没有受到email，是什么情况？要不要发个信问问？难道是因为上周是感恩节？希望有经验的虫友指教~~~~谢谢！ 知乎，中文互联网高质量的问答社区和创作者聚集的原创内容平台，于 2011 年 1 月正式上线，以「让人们更好的分享知识、经验和见解，找到自己的解答」为品牌使命。知乎凭借认真、专业、友善的社区氛围、独特的产品机制以及结构化和易获得的优质内容，聚集了中文互联网科技、商业、影视 我经过三个月的补实验和修改论文，年后投回，两天就review结束了现在是Pending Final Recommendation状态已经4天了。 并且PNAS的主编不是我的文章的editor给我发了封信全文如下： Your manusc […] Does awaiting ae for your assumptions of reviewers scores mean that aes is pnas pending recommendation to awaiting ae assignment reporter. This is the “consultative” part of the pilot. The status of the paper has since changed from "Under Review" to "Decision Pending", and recently, maybe 4 days ago, the status has changed to "Decision Pending Approval". ' Is there any chance it will proceed to 'Under Review'? What does pending recommendation mean PNAS? Answer: The change in status from ‘Under review’ to ‘Pending recommendation’ means that peer review of your paper is done and the Associate Editor (AE) will now go through the reviews and give his/her recommendation on whether it should be accepted, rejected, or revised. Editorial staff will contact the authors to secure new prearranged reviewers. Months of work. bProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) Information for authors. However, in your case, they decided to review it. Exposure and it for example, pending final decision finally hit the out to our expertise and answer. What does pending decision mean on journal submission? Pnas under editorial board review pending recommendation The Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences has unusual submission procedures. Do you think the fact that "under editor review" was skipped means it's going to be a rejection? What happened? Now it went to Pending Recommendation. Most submissions go through Direct Review, which is similar to the traditional review process at most scholarly journals, except that "Authors must recommend three appropriate Editorial Board members, three NAS members who are expert in the paper's Ready to publish in a high-impact multidisciplinary journal from the National Academy of Sciences? Explore PNAS author guidelines and publishing resources. Review the peer review process, ethics guidelines, and editorial standards at PNAS. ' I expected the article to change to 'Under Review. I know that this means the peer review process has been completed, and the reviewers have submitted their recommendations to the journal's editors. 投稿PNAS, 通过了editorial board review, 进入到Under Editor Review，然后就是under review，但是同一天就显示Pending Final Recommendation，这到底是有没有送出去外审阿，还是被直接拒了？还是等审稿人的回复？ What does a status change from "Editor Assigned" to "Editor Invited" mean? Waiting time As it has been only two weeks since you submitted your paper and only one week since the status changed to ‘Awaiting Editor Assignment,’ you may need to wait for some time, let’s say, two-three weeks, for the next status update.